Vol. 31 No. 1 (2023)
Academic Critique and Polemics

Broad, and yet too narrow. A critical review of a commendable book

Zoran Janjetović
Institute for Recent History of Serbia, Belgrade

Published 2023-04-26

Keywords

  • Igor Vukadinović,
  • Kosovo and Metohija,
  • Albanians,
  • autonomy,
  • Josip Broz Tito

How to Cite

Janjetović, Z. (2023). Broad, and yet too narrow. A critical review of a commendable book. Currents of History, 31(1), 291-310. https://doi.org/10.31212/tokovi.2023.1.jan.291-310

Abstract

This paper is a critical review of Igor Vukadinović’s book, The Autonomy of Kosovo and Metohija in Serbia (1945–1969), (Belgrade: Balkanological Institute SANU, 2021), in which I tried to point out its both good and bad sides, primarily its one-sided conclusions. 

Summary: The review deals critically with the book of Igor Vukadinović on Kosovo’s autonomy. Vukadinović’s diligence as a researcher is lauded, but it is pointed out that his conclusions are biased. Vukadinović views events, processes and persons from a narrow national perspective, reaching thus conclusions that are only partly true or insufficiently grounded in historical sources. For that reason, he did not manage to utilize in the best way huge quantity of materials that he had found in Serbian and Albanian archives and gleaned from relevant literature in several languages (including Albanian).